Guide · Reviewing a take-off
The ten costliest quantity take-off mistakes in villa projects, and how to review a bill of quantities before approving it
Most quantity take-off mistakes are not arithmetic mistakes but method mistakes: an opening not deducted, an item counted twice from two sheets, a unit written as linear metres and priced as square metres, waste not added, stairs and aluminium taken off by estimate. Each of them moves the total of a 400 m² villa by thousands of riyals, some by tens of thousands. An effective review does not redo the take-off from scratch; it goes through ten specific points in a fixed order and asks of every figure "where did it come from". This guide presents the ten, and for each mistake: how to catch it, and what it costs if it gets through.
Why take-off mistakes cost more than pricing mistakes
A mistake in a unit price is discovered quickly because the price is compared with the market. A mistake in a quantity hides behind a figure that looks reasonable, and it compounds: the wrong quantity is multiplied by the price, then by indirect costs, profit and tax. In lump-sum contracts the contractor bears it alone, and in remeasurement contracts it surfaces in the payment certificates as a dispute with the owner. Worse, once the bill of quantities is approved it becomes the reference against which every later change is measured.
The ten mistakes
1. Forgetting to deduct openings from blockwork, plaster and paint
The wall is calculated as the room perimeter times the height, then doors and windows are deducted. Whoever takes off in a hurry takes the gross and leaves the deduction to the market "because it offsets the waste". The result is an increase of 8 to 12% in the blockwork, plaster and paint items, which are among the largest items in the villa.
How to catch it: Pick one room with a door and a window and calculate it by hand. If the bill's quantity matches the gross before deduction, the whole bill was not deducted. The recognised measurement rule in RICS NRM 2 is that openings larger than a certain threshold are always deducted, and the office fixes its threshold in the measurement record.
2. Duplicating an item from two sheets
The same element appears on the plan, in the section and on the detail sheet. Whoever takes off sheet by sheet counts the stairs on the plan and then again on the stair detail sheet, or counts the beams on the ceiling plan and then on the reinforcement sheet. Duplicating one large item can add 3 to 5% to the total.
How to catch it: Sort the bill by element rather than by sheet and look for items with similar descriptions. Then ask of every item: which sheet was it taken from? An item without one specific sheet is suspect.
3. A wrong or inconsistent unit
Stair risers in linear metres are priced as square metres, insulation in square metres is written as cubic metres, and steel in tonnes is written as kilograms on one line and tonnes on another. A unit error changes the price by multiples, not percentages, and it is the easiest mistake to catch and the most frequent in hand-written bills.
How to catch it: The unit column is reviewed on its own from top to bottom before anything else. One unit per material throughout the bill: concrete m³, steel tonne, blockwork, plaster, paint and tiles m², stairs, partitions and frames lm, doors, windows and fixtures by count. Any exception is explained in the description.
4. Ignoring waste or doubling it
The net quantity from the drawing is not bought as it is. Tiles need a 7 to 10% addition for cutting and breakage, blocks 3 to 5%, and steel 3 to 5% for cutting lengths. The mistake comes from two directions: ignoring waste entirely, so less than needed is bought, or adding it to the quantity and then again in the unit price, so it is paid twice.
How to catch it: Ask: are the bill quantities net or inclusive of waste? The answer must be one for the whole bill and written in its preamble. The convention is that the bill is net and waste sits inside the unit price, but what matters is the agreement, not the method.
5. Stairs and aluminium by estimate
Stairs are often taken off as "complete staircase: lump sum" or by estimating their area from the plan. The right way is to take off treads and risers in linear metres from the detail sheet by the number of steps, the handrail in linear metres, and the inclined slab in cubic metres. Aluminium likewise: taken off from the aluminium schedule on the architectural sheet unit by unit with its dimensions, not by estimating the area of the openings. In a published test of a twin villa, the riser cladding of one floor's stairs came out as 22.00 lm from 22 numbered steps on the detail sheet, and a terrace door frame as 8.84 lm from a perimeter of 2×(1.00+3.42), and neither figure can be reached by estimate.
How to catch it: Any stair or aluminium item whose unit is "lump sum" or whose quantity is a rounded figure is re-measured from the detail sheet and the aluminium schedule.
6. Mixing net quantities with priced quantities, and inconsistent terms
The engineering office receives a "quantity take-off" and finds it priced at a contractor's prices, or is asked for a "muqayasa" and delivers an unpriced bill. Confusion over terms wastes both parties' time and brings one contractor's prices into a document that is supposed to be neutral. The definitions of the four terms and their places are in the guide to the difference between take-off, bill of quantities, estimate and site measurement.
How to catch it: The document's title and preamble state: an unpriced bill of quantities, a priced one, or an estimate. And the price and total columns are empty in the neutral bill.
7. A wrong drawing scale or level
The sheet was printed on A3 while its scale is written for A1, or a PDF file was exported "fit to page" so its scale changed by an unknown ratio, or the storey height was taken as 3.00 m from the elevation while the section says 3.30 m. The error here hits every item on the sheet by the same ratio, and can reach 20% or more.
How to catch it: Before any measurement, measure a written dimension on the sheet (a room length, or the column grid) and compare it with the measurement. If they differ, the scale is wrong. And heights are taken from the sections, not the elevations.
8. Forgotten items outside the architectural sheets
The architect takes off what is visible on the plan: walls, floors and doors. Items that appear on other sheets or not at all are forgotten: excavation, backfill and foundation level, insulation under floors and over the roof, formwork and its labour, concrete curing, scaffolding, cleaning and waste removal, temporary site facilities. Together these can reach 10 to 15% of the shell cost.
How to catch it: A fixed list of work sections (earthworks, concrete, steel, formwork, blockwork, insulation, plaster, flooring, paint, doors and windows, electrical, plumbing, air conditioning, temporary works) is compared with the bill section by section. An empty section is questioned.
9. Relying on schedules printed on the sheet without verification
Many sheets carry a ready area schedule or door schedule, and it is copied as it is. But the schedule may be from an earlier revision of the design, or may total areas in a way that does not match the item's unit. Blind copying copies the old error.
How to catch it: A sample of three rows from the printed schedule is taken and measured from the plan. A match confirms the schedule; a difference discards it. In the twin-villa test mentioned, a room area of 4.000×3.250 = 13.00 m² was confirmed by two independent readings that matched the printed area, and that is the approach: the printed schedule is evidence to be tested, not a reference to be copied.
10. No measurement record
The mistake that creates all the others. A bill of quantities whose figures have no source can only be reviewed by re-measuring it in full, so nobody reviews it and it is approved on trust. The measurement record writes for every item: the sheet, the dimensions used, the calculation, and what was deducted. Its presence turns the review from days into an hour.
How to catch it: Ask for the calculation basis of any three random items. If producing them takes more than minutes, the record does not exist.
Ten-minute bill of quantities checklist
| # | Check | Reveals |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Measure a written dimension on every sheet and compare | Scale (7) |
| 2 | Go through the unit column on its own | Units (3) |
| 3 | Calculate one room with a door and a window by hand | Deduction of openings (1) |
| 4 | Sort by element and look for repetition | Duplication (2) |
| 5 | Read the bill's preamble: net or with waste? priced or not? | Waste (4) and terminology (6) |
| 6 | Review every "lump sum" or rounded item in stairs and aluminium | Estimating (5) |
| 7 | Compare the thirteen work sections with the bill | Forgotten items (8) |
| 8 | Test three rows of any printed schedule | Blind copying (9) |
| 9 | Ask for the calculation basis of three random items | The record (10) |
| 10 | Compare each section's total with the expected rate per square metre | Any large remaining error |
The tenth check is the safety net: the concrete of a two-storey 400 m² villa falls around 0.35 to 0.45 m³ per built square metre (a rough assumption for illustration that varies with the structural system), and any large departure from that calls for a question even if the nine checks passed.
What this looks like on screen
KAM Estimator was built around the idea of the tenth mistake: every item in the resulting bill carries its sheet, its position and its calculation basis in writing, so the ten items above are reviewed from the bill itself without going back to the sheets. And every sheet is read twice independently: agreement marks the item "Confirmed", and disagreement or a visual count marks it "Review" and keeps it in front of you with a note instead of hiding it. The item needing review in the twin villa was a sound-insulation-rated door counted from the sheet's symbols rather than from a schedule, so it appeared with the "Review" flag for the engineer to verify. Details and the published test figures are on the engineering offices page.
The app does not replace the review; it makes it possible in its time: the engineer reviews what was flagged instead of re-measuring everything.
References
- RICS New Rules of Measurement (NRM) · Measurement rules and the deduction of openings, checked
- Saudi Building Code · The requirements that affect quantities (thicknesses and insulation), checked
FAQ
Review your bill on screen
Every item in the bill the app produces carries its sheet, its position and its calculation basis, and disputed items are flagged "Review". Try it on a drawing whose quantities you know.
This guide was published on . The prices mentioned are examples from published references with their dates, not a quotation.
